When it comes to choosing a fishing reel , there’s one question that pops up time after time… spinning reel or baitcaster?
Honestly, both styles have their place and will catch you plenty of fish. While each has a loyal club of followers, who reckon theirs is the only way to go - truth is… it really comes down to a couple of key questions:
What species of fish are you chasing?
How much control would you like?
What type of fishing do you do?
We’re certainly not here to crown a winner of this debate, instead, we’re here to give you some handy facts on each, to help you make the right choice.
Quick Links
Spinning reels
If you’re new to fishing, a spinning reel is the perfect place to begin. They’re simple to use, super versatile and make quite a cost-effective option that’ll have you wetting a line in no time. If you’re looking at doing some light tackle fishing, spinning reels are hard to beat. They also handle casting into the wind and nighttime use much better than their baitcaster counterpart. Whether you plan on flicking soft plastics in the river or dropping baits offshore, if you want a reel that can do a bit of everything, a spinning reel is what you need!
Why choose a spinning reel
Easy to use – the ultimate choice for beginners
As versatile as they come
Great for light lines and lures
Less tangles and birds nests
Great bang for your buck
Check out this step by step guide from our mate Sammy on how to cast a spinning reel .
Baitcaster reels
Baitcasters are the perfect pick for fishos looking for optimal control and accuracy. Although small in stature, these beauties deliver big in the power department and make chasing big fish in tight structure a whole lot easier. You won’t get too far fishing tight structure without pinpoint casting - lucky that is something baitcasters do the best! With your thumb in total control of the spool, it allows you to put your bait or lure exactly where you want it. Baitcaster’s reward practice and although it may take a bit more time to master, once you’ve got it down pat – you’ll never look back!
Why choose a baitcaster reel?
Pinpoint casting has never been easier
Built for power – in a small package
Designed to take heavier lines and lures
Faster engagement – when your fishing tight structure, that split second matters
Better control over lure speed and drop
Check out our step by step guide on how to cast a baitcaster .
So, which reel should you choose?
Still on the fence? No worries, here’s something to help you make your mind up:
Go a spinning reel if you’re new to fishing, want versatility by the bucketload, or spend most of your time fishing light tackle.
Go a baitcaster reel if you’re chasing big structure-dwelling species like barra, mangrove jack and murray cod, plan on using heavier gear, or want the ultimate control of your casting.
At the end of the day, there’s no “BETTER” reel – just the right reel for the right job! It doesn’t matter if you’re serious about spinning reels or think baitcasters are the bee’s knees, what’s really important is your out there giving it a crack – and hopefully sorting out dinner while you’re at it.
Frequently asked questions: spinning reels vs baitcasters
1. What is the difference between a spinning reel and a baitcaster?
The main difference between a spinning reel and a baitcaster is how the spool releases line. A spinning reel has a fixed spool that lets line peel off freely, making it easier for beginners. A baitcaster on the other hand uses a rotating spool, providing you much better casting accuracy, power and control — but it may take a bit of practice to master.
2. Is a spinning reel better for beginners?
Simply… Yes! Spinning reels are generally better for beginners, as they’re easier to cast, less likely to cause tangles and work well with light lines and lures. If you’re just getting started, a spinning reel is usually the simplest and most forgiving option.
3. When should you use a baitcaster reel?
A baitcaster reel is best used when you need accuracy and power — especially when fishing tight structure like timber, mangroves or rock bars. They’re ideal for heavier lines and lures and targeting species like barra, mangrove jack and murray cod.
4. Can you cast further with a spinning reel or baitcaster?
Spinning reels often cast lighter lures further and handle windy conditions much better. However, baitcasters can still achieve excellent casting distance once they are set up correctly and with the help of heavier lures - Casting distance ultimately comes down to lure weight, setup and overall skill level.
5. Do baitcasters tangle more than spinning reels?
Yes, baitcasters are more prone to tangles! If you’re casting this type of reel for the first time, you will undoubtedly get the odd birds nest. Because the spool rotates during casting, incorrect brake settings or poor thumb control can cause overruns. With practice and proper setup, though, tangles become far less common – this is why baitcasters aren’t the perfect choice for kids.
About the author
BCFing Experts
The BCFing Experts have done more than their fair share of boating, camping, fishing, hiking, four-wheel driving and much much more! Whether you're tackling tough tracks in Tassie or chasing big barra up North, the BCFing Experts have the know-how to make your next outdoor adventure a pearler
Read More